Hartshill Pumping Station Caldecote

Warwickshire 

Key information

Purpose of the pumping station

Severn Trent had a legal obligation to reduce phosphorous in the Sketchley Brook and the only way to do this was to remove the treated discharge from our Hinckley Treatment Works. This meant the wastewater had to be piped to the treatment works at Hartshill instead. The Hartshill Pumping Station at Caldecote is part of the network to get it there.

What is the odour?

There are two main types of odour – general sewage and septic sewage. Sewage can become septic if it stagnates which can happen at times of low flow or extreme temperatures and gives off hydrogen sulphide (the rotten egg smell). Following residents’ reports, ST has been monitoring the network and addressing any septicity issues found. This is done through dosing with chemicals at the Hinckley pumping station.  ST also used tankers to bring more treated water from other sites to flush the pumping station. There are currently no septicity issues.

Why is there an odour?

When the pumping station was built, changes were made to the design and these need to be re-assessed. A revised Odour Impact Assessment (OIA) is being carried out. One aspect that is being explored is some form of cover which was part of the design but not implemented. ST is committed to taking action and has a team exploring all opportunities but this unfortunately won’t be a quick fix.

Immediate action

Whilst the main solutions are in development, we’re looking at ways to monitor and reduce the odour impact.

Odour monitors are to be installed. Please note that the monitors can pick up only hydrogen sulphide and not general sewage odours but will help identify septicity issues.

We’ve installed an atomiser which in effect, deodorises the air by emitting a fine spray to ‘cover’ the odour. We can alter the dilution of the mixture and try other scents. We’d appreciate your feedback so that we can decide whether a more permanent version of the equipment is a good idea.

Visual impact

We’ve listened to residents’ concerns about the visual impact of the station. We’re working with the landowner to identify suitable native tree species and space to plant them.

We’ve sourced screening that we can put in place if deemed appropriate by residents.

Lighting

Residents have raised concerns about the brightness of the lights on site, their use and the fact they’ve sometimes been left on overnight. The outside lights came on when the internal kiosk lights were switched on so we’ve disconnected them. Installation of automated lighting is booked for 21 October. This will switch the outside lights off after an hour.

The light stands will be re-painted green to make them less obvious at residents’ request.

Maintenance visits

There’s been more site activity than there would be in normal operation while the assets are completed and tested. Once ready, the site will be handed over to the operational side of the business and we expect there to be approximately two routine site visits per month and perhaps twice a year, the pumps will need to be lifted and cleaned. Lifting the pumps requires a crane hence that will be brought in as and when needed. There will also be cleansing of the pumping station regularly.

Toxicity

Whilst deeply unpleasant, any hydrogen sulphide emitted would be at very low levels. Some ST staff work in locations with much higher levels and on a regular basis and they haven’t suffered ill health as a result. Please do speak to your GP if you have particular concerns.

Track condition

Concerns have been raised about the condition of the track to the pumping station due to the additional heavy vehicle movements. The track is a privately owned bridleway and we’re exploring the possibility of making some one-off repairs.

Background

Residents have been reporting issues including odours coming from the pumping station in Caldecote for a long time and are deeply frustrated at the lack of action to date. Following complaints and liaison with some members of the local community, we set up this meeting so all voices in your hamlet could be heard.

The first thing we want to say is that we’re sorry. This has caused distress and upset to many people in the area. We didn’t get this right, and we want to fix it.

We are taking this seriously and are working to put in an effective long-term solution.

Why we have a pumping station at Caldecote

Hinckley Treatment Works takes wastewater from thousands of homes and businesses in the area and, after treatment it’s safe to release and is discharged into Sketchley Brook, a small watercourse that rises in Hinckley and flows into the River Anker.

Treatment regulations are frequently updated and to further improve the Sketchley Brook we needed to reduce the amount of phosphorus entering it. As well as improving Hinckley Treatment Works, we built an underground pipeline to Hartshill Treatment Works, 13km away, so the two plants could share the load. To help move already-treated sewage from Hinckley to Harshill, we needed to build two new pumping stations, including one in Caldecote.

Why is there an odour?

The wastewater flows through the pumping station and passes through the ‘wet well’ – an underground holding tank at the station – which is not covered. This can mean you experience odours from the flows in the surrounding area.

The wet well needs regular maintenance, with workers climbing into the chamber to check its condition. Originally, we’d designed this wet well to have a concrete cover. However, during the project, we reviewed the safety risks for our workers entering an enclosed wet well. Our review decided the risks were too high, meaning the design changed to remove the cover.

When this change happened, we should have gone back to the original Odour Impact Assessment we’d carried out originally, but unfortunately this did not happen. We’re now carrying out a new Odour Impact Assessment assessed based on the actual final construction – the wet well without a cover.

What is the odour?

There are two main sources for odours coming from this type of operation – general sewage itself, and septic sewage. Before it leaves Hinckley it goes through the full sewage treatment process, which should remove most of the general sewage smell. However, it can become septic if it stands and stagnates. This can happen at times of low flow or hot weather, when it gives off hydrogen sulphide – the rotten egg smell.

Following residents’ reports, we’ve been monitoring the network and working to prevent any septic sewage issues. We’re dosing the treated sewage with extra chemicals at the Hinckley pumping station.  At the moment there should be no issues with septic sewage, and we’re keeping it under close watch at Hinckley.

What is being done to stop the odour

While we can work to reduce septicity issues from your local network, clearly in the long term we all want a solution that works for everyone, and we’ve already begun work on this. To solve this permanently will likely mean a major construction project. To make sure we do this properly, we’re going through the full process to plan what needs to happen. This has already begun and we’ve instigated a fast-track scoping exercise. 

Clearly you want us to solve this as quickly as possible. It’s a complex job at an important site and we want to make sure we solve this for everyone permanently. Depending on the option it could take 12 months or more to implement.

Potential ways we might address the odour issues will include, but aren’t limited to, new covers over the wet well. Obviously we need to make sure what we do will fix the problem, is technically possible, won’t cause further safety issues or harm the local environment. We hope to be able to share the preferred solution with you by the end of the year.

We’ll make sure we keep the Caldecote community informed of progress and will consult with you where we can.

What we’re doing in the meantime

To further reduce the odour impact on you and your neighbours, we’ve installed a rotary atomiser at the site. We use these successfully at other sites – they work by deodorising the air by sending out a fine spray.

This was the best option to make a difference quickly, but it’s not perfect. It can’t operate non-stop as it must be manually check and refilled and given time to cool down between uses.

What we’re doing now is putting a permanent atomiser inside the wet well. This will be better as it can operate 24/7 and, having multiple jets which are angled into the well, mixes with the air more effectively. It’s on order with a lead time of 6 to 8 weeks. We hope to put it in before the end of the year, but it may fall into January.

Toxicity

Some residents asked us about the safety of any fumes coming from the site. While we accept it’s not pleasant, any hydrogen sulphide emitted is at very low levels. The long-term safety limits set for people working with hydrogen sulphide (including some Severn Trent staff) are much higher than the amounts being generated by this site.

We'd also like to assure residents that the atomiser mist is safe. We have confirmation from the manufacturer that the scents used have been assessed in accordance with applicable chemical classification requirements and do not meet the criteria for hazard classification under GB regulations.

None of the ingredients are deemed hazardous, but, as with all things, individual sensitivities can vary. There is one ingredient that is commonly used as a fragrance/flavouring in products which may cause an allergic reaction but no more so than any product you'd find in a supermarket. We’re moving to a product which does not contain this ingredient. 

If anyone has any specific health concerns we’d advise they speak to their GP.

Planting

Residents are concerned about the visual impact of the station and the planting around the site, and we agree with you that it needs to be better. We’re going to remove any plants which have died back and add additional planting to create a denser screen, reducing the visual impact of the station.

Despite our efforts we’ve been unable to source safe, native, evergreen planting so we propose to plant blackthorn, hawthorn and beech. In order to get them established as soon as possible we’re sourcing large-sized whips - younger, smaller plants that can create a screen relatively quickly.

The ideal planting season is from now through to March and we’ll plant as soon as possible once we have the agreement with the landowner. The supplier is already on standby for the purchase and planting.  

Lighting

Residents had raised concerns about the brightness of the lights, their use, and the fact they have at times been left on overnight.

We’ve disconnected the floodlights from the kiosk lights and have booked to have an automated lights system fitted on 9 November. Once this is working, the lights will go off automatically an hour after use.

In addition, we’ve repainted the light stands green to make them less obtrusive and we’re also looking at options to recolour the kiosk that is on site.

Track condition

Some residents asked about the condition of the track due to the additional heavy vehicle movements needed while we were building the pumping station. We’re getting quotes for making some improvements to the bridleway, which is privately-owned. Any work will be subject to agreement by the landowner.

What else can you do?

As we have described, the odour issue stems from the wastewater flowing through the pumping station. As this an integral part of our wastewater network, we can’t switch off or divert these flows to stop the odours. Until we have installed the main solution, we cannot prevent the odours.  We absolutely understand that this is not what you want to hear but we must be open and honest.

While we work towards a permanent solution, the best interim measure will be putting in the permanent atomiser we mentioned above, and we hope this will make a noticeable difference.

Another option we’re going to try is temporary screening along the boundary fence to screen the pipework and assets from general view. Although it won’t have a major effect on the odour issue it may help with concerns about the atomiser mist and the look of the site. We’d welcome feedback once it’s in place.

Interim options are limited, but we’ll continue to explore and where possible, put in place, any further measures that might help to mask or deflect the odour.

Compensation

Once again, we’re sincerely sorry about the impact this has had on residents. We acknowledge our part in this and are serious about fixing it. The project team you have met with will listen to you, and act on what you say - as soon as safely and practicably possible.

Unfortunately, we cannot offer individual compensation. However, we want to find a way to give something back to your local community. We’re open to suggestions that would benefit the people and/or environment of the Caldecote hamlet.

At the meeting we spoke about the Severn Trent Community Fund and feel this may have been confused with compensation. Our Community Fund is a separate grant programme rather than a compensation scheme. It is overseen by an independent customer panel and supports local groups and charities. The customer panel looks at applications for grants that would help new projects that meet a genuine community need or to help organisations that deliver vital community services to continue what they do.

Future flows

We were asked whether an increase in the population of Hinckley would mean an increase in flows from the treatment works and therefore more odour. We’ve built the system to cater for more capacity in the future, so this won’t result in more issues. 

Get in touch

Helen 

Severn Trent Community Communications Officer

07703 718436